Determining the value of a piece of American-made furniture is rarely a simple matter of looking up a price in a book. Value depends on a combination of factors — age, condition, rarity, maker, provenance, and current market demand all play a role. Bob and Ellen Tuttle, drawing on more than 30 years of refinishing and dealing experience, offered practical guidance for anyone trying to understand what a piece might be worth.
Key Factors That Influence Value
Age and Period
Older does not always mean more valuable. A piece from a highly sought-after period — such as early American Federal or mid-century modern — may command far higher prices than something simply old but common. Knowing which periods are in demand is essential.
Maker and Brand
Furniture from recognized American manufacturers of the early-to-mid 20th century often carries identifiable marks, labels, or construction traits. A piece by a well-regarded maker can be worth considerably more than an unmarked equivalent. The Tuttles' companion essay on brand names offers a comparative listing of major manufacturers from 1900–1950.
Condition and Originality
Original finish, intact hardware, and the absence of major repairs or replacements all contribute positively to value. A refinished piece may lose value among purist collectors, while a well-executed restoration can enhance appeal for buyers seeking a usable, beautiful piece for the home.
Rarity and Desirability
Even a modest piece can be valuable if few were made or few survive. Conversely, a well-made but widely produced item may hold steady but modest value. Regional preferences also shift — what is prized in the Northeast may be less sought after in the South, and vice versa.
Construction and Materials
Solid hardwood construction, hand-cut joinery, and high-quality secondary woods all signal craftsmanship that supports higher valuation. Understanding whether a piece is solid or veneer — a topic the Tuttles explored in another Furniture Facts essay — is a critical first step in assessment.
A Practical Approach
Bob and Ellen encouraged a methodical approach: examine the piece carefully for marks and labels, assess its construction, research comparable sold items, and consider having it evaluated by an experienced dealer or appraiser. They reminded readers that sentimental value and market value are not the same — and that the true worth of a piece often lies in how it fits into a home and a family's story.
← Back to Furniture Facts